How to Choose a Romantasy Editor: What to Look For and What to Ask
Romantasy readers want it all: a love story that makes them ache, a world they can get lost in, and stakes high enough to break both. That’s a lot to balance in one book, and it’s why romantasy is one of the hardest genres to edit well.
If you’re writing romantasy, the editor you choose needs to understand both halves of the genre. Here’s what to look for, what to ask, and the mistakes that send romantasy readers running.
Why Romantasy Needs a Specialist
A fantasy editor might nail your magic system but treat the romance as a subplot. A romance editor might love your slow burn but miss the holes in your worldbuilding. Romantasy needs an editor who can hold both at once.
A good romantasy editor will look at:
The romance arc. Is the relationship the heart of the story? Does the tension build, break, and resolve in a way that feels earned?
The worldbuilding. Are the rules of your world clear and consistent? Does the reader learn them without drowning in info dumps?
The balance. When the plot takes over, does the romance disappear for fifty pages? When the romance heats up, does the war, quest, or curse suddenly stop mattering?
The stakes. Do the fantasy stakes and the romantic stakes feed each other? The best romantasy makes loving someone the most dangerous choice a character can make.
1. Look for Romantasy Experience
Ask potential editors how much romantasy they’ve edited, not just fantasy or romance. The genre has its own rhythms and reader expectations, from fated mates to enemies to lovers across warring kingdoms.
Better yet, ask which romantasy books they read for fun. Editors who love the genre know what readers are hungry for.
2. Make Sure They Can Handle Your Heat Level
Romantasy covers everything from closed-door fairy-tale romance to very spicy fae courts. Tell your editor your heat level up front, and make sure they’re comfortable editing it without trying to push it up or down.
3. Ask How They Handle Worldbuilding
Romantasy manuscripts often run long, and much of that length is worldbuilding. Ask your editor how they approach it. Will they track your magic system, political factions, and place names for consistency? Will they flag where the worldbuilding slows the pacing? A good editor keeps a style sheet of your world’s names and rules so nothing contradicts itself by book three.
4. Get a Sample Edit
A sample edit shows you exactly how an editor works. When you get it back, ask yourself:
Did they understand both the romance and the fantasy?
Do their notes keep your voice and your world intact?
Did they explain why, not just what to change?
Do you feel excited to revise?
5. Know Which Edit Your Book Needs
Big-picture problems like a sagging middle, a romance that fades mid-book, or a confusing magic system call for a content edit. If the story works but the prose needs polish, a line edit is the right fit. Our guide to content edits, line edits, and proofreads breaks down the difference.
6. Plan for Your Word Count
Because romantasy books often run 100,000 words or more, your editing budget will be higher than for a shorter romance. Get a clear per-word quote before you book, and check our guide on how much it costs to edit a novel to plan ahead.
Red Flags to Watch For
They treat the romance as secondary to the “real” fantasy plot.
They want to cut your worldbuilding instead of helping you weave it in.
They don’t read the genre or seem unfamiliar with its tropes.
No sample edit, no contract, no clear price.
Why Romantasy Authors Choose Keele Publishing
Romantasy is one of our specialties. Our founder, Cindy Ray Hale, has edited for LJ Andrews, the USA Today and Sunday Times bestselling author whose romantasy series The Ever King was acquired by Penguin Random House imprints Berkley and Ace. Many of the editors on our team specialize in romantasy, and they bring that same bestseller-level standard to every manuscript, at every heat level.
Every service is priced per word, with no hidden fees, and new clients can get a free sample edit of their first 1,000 words.
Find Your Romantasy Editor
Your world and your love story both deserve an editor who gets them. When you’re ready, request a free sample edit and we’ll match you with the editor who fits your book.
Comments